The Board › Anything That's Rock N Roll

Jimmy Iovine on American Idol

Started by SingsInFrench on Jan 9, 2011 · 12 replies · 839 views · from the Mudcrutch Farm message board archive (read-only)

  1. Jimmy Iovine will be the in-house mentor (not judge) for the next season of American Idol. Will this make the show better? Will you watch?

    I have to admit I'm interested to see what Jimmy will bring to the show.

    http://www.americanidol.com/news/view/pid/3732/

  2. I don't watch "Idol." If Iovine's not a judge, I don't think I'll watch...although it might be as kick to watch Steven Tyler.

  3. His mentoring sessions will be televised though. I'm guessing he will work with the contestants on their chosen songs before they perform.

  4. Sorry, not even Jimmy can get me to watch that nauseating show.

  5. Wow. I'm with Ref on this one.

  6. Not interested in that show no matter who is involved in it.

  7. I'm surprised he would do that show. Odd. And, no, I won't be watching.

  8. I watch it - I admit it! I love the mix of delusion, drama and the very occasional talent. What amazes me is when someone who so very obviously can't carry a tune is encouraged by family/friends to audition - I just don't get that.

    Jimmy Iovine? can't figure that one out, must be paying him a boatload and he probably gets first crack at the newest pop singers now that Simon is gone.

  9. Embarrassingly I did catch some of the show last night. They introduced Iovine as the producer talent that will be behind the season winner.

    Tom Petty got a mention when they did a highlight of Ionvine's past work and they flashed a photo of the band. Pretty nice.

  10. I was in a packed bar last night when this came on. When they mentioned TPATH and showed the photo, a bunch of us put our fists in the air and yelled "YEAH!!!".

  11. We were eating lunch the other day at work and there was a print ad that had a picture of the judges for the show in People magazine and our new legal assistant (young) said, look at that, they have just some random guy standing there. LOL It was Iovine.

  12. I understand the music business has changed. There are so many great bands/singers playing in clubs that could easily beat most of the singers on AI. So many of the singers on there they gush about I don't think are that good. They waste so much time with the goofballs at the auditions. Carrie Underwood has done well, not many others. Bottom line, it seems about how they can make a buck of some new talent to me.

  13. If Iovine is producer of talent, maybe he can get them to ask Tom to be one of the guest mentors who coaches the contestants on singing their songs and helping them with the arrangements. I would watch it that night if the contestants get to have a Tom Petty night. I did watch the episode where Shaina Twain coached the contestants; she did an excellent job with the group.

    Time will only tell if the judges actually make a difference. Without Simon, I do not think the show will be that good--he was the only judge that would tell the truth when the contestants were horrible and was usually spot on. Since the Kellie Pickler group, the contestants have not had the charisma or personality to get me to take the time to watch the show.

    As for success from the show, Kellie Pickler has done alright on the country front. Carrie Underwood is one of the queens of country--due to a great choice of songs and a great voice. Kelly Clarkson has done well also. Oddly enough, Kelly Clarkson did a duet with Reba which was very successful, and she has a second duet that debuted on the CMA Awards with Jason Aldean (she sounded great). I wonder if she will do a country album in the future.

Keep the conversation going

The board is closed, but the Farm isn't. Pick this thread back up in our Facebook group, or add your own memories to the Fan Vault.

Join the Facebook group