The fights he picked

Business & legal

Tom Petty went bankrupt rather than be sold with his contract, made his label hold an album to $8.98, and turned the record business into the subject of a whole album. Here is that side of the story in one place: the labels, the prices, the songwriting cases and the times he told politicians to stop playing his songs.

1975

Record labels

Shelter Records breaks up Mudcrutch but keeps Petty

After moving to Los Angeles in 1974, Mudcrutch signed with Shelter Records, the independent label co-run by Leon Russell, and recorded in Tulsa and at Russell's Encino home. Their only single, "Depot Street" (backed with "Wild Eyes"), came out in 1975 and did not chart. When the band failed to deliver a follow-up the label was satisfied with, Shelter broke up the group in late 1975 but kept Petty under contract as a songwriter and solo artist, which led to the formation of the Heartbreakers.

Outcome: Mudcrutch was dissolved; Petty stayed on Shelter and formed the Heartbreakers with Mike Campbell and Benmont Tench.

Sources: Mudcrutch - Wikipedia (citing Goldmine, July 13, 1990) · Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers - Wikipedia

Mudcrutch's Shelter Records contract letter, July 1974
Mudcrutch's Shelter Records contract letter, July 1974 · shared by Danny Roberts
1979

Publishing

Settlement creates Backstreet Records and returns Petty's publishing

The dispute ended with Petty signing to Backstreet Records, a new MCA subsidiary label set up for the deal; History.com puts the new contract at about $3 million. Contemporary reporting in BAM said the settlement freed him from his Shelter obligations, gave him control of his song publishing, raised the band's royalty rate and paid the Heartbreakers a substantial sum, with Petty barred from discussing the details. Damn the Torpedoes was released on Backstreet on October 19, 1979, and went on to multi-platinum sales.

Outcome: Petty stayed with MCA through Backstreet but regained his publishing and left Shelter behind.

Sources: BAM magazine, December 14, 1979 (Petty Archives copy) · May 23, 1979: Tom Petty defies his record label and files for bankruptcy - History.com · Damn the Torpedoes (album) - Wikipedia

A signed, framed Damn the Torpedoes, the first Backstreet album
A signed, framed Damn the Torpedoes, the first Backstreet album · shared by NightDriver
1979

Record labels · March 1979

ABC Records sold to MCA; Petty refuses the transfer

In March 1979 ABC Records, which distributed Shelter and had released Petty's first two albums, was sold to MCA Records. Petty argued that his contract could not be transferred without his consent and refused to move to MCA, while MCA maintained the contract was valid and sued him for breach of contract. MCA also obtained a court order barring him from negotiating with other labels while the dispute went on, and the third album was held back.

Outcome: The dispute delayed the album that became Damn the Torpedoes, originally due in May 1979.

Sources: Robert Hilburn, Los Angeles Times, July 27, 1979 (Petty Archives copy) · Damn the Torpedoes (album) - Wikipedia · BAM magazine, December 14, 1979 (Petty Archives copy)

1979

Record labels · May 1979

Petty files for bankruptcy to fight the MCA contract

Having paid for the new album's sessions himself, Petty was roughly half a million dollars in debt, and on May 23, 1979 he filed for bankruptcy (a Chapter XI proceeding). The filing was a tactic: he hoped the court would void a contract he said he had signed under duress. Petty also publicly said he would not be bought and sold like a commodity.

Outcome: The filing gave Petty leverage that led to a negotiated settlement later in 1979.

Sources: May 23, 1979: Tom Petty defies his record label and files for bankruptcy - History.com · Robert Hilburn, Los Angeles Times, July 27, 1979 (Petty Archives copy) · Tom Petty - Wikipedia

1981

Prices

Hard Promises held at $8.98 after list-price fight

MCA planned to issue Hard Promises at a new 'superstar' list price of $9.98, a dollar above the standard $8.98, following other big releases priced that way. Petty objected publicly and threatened to withhold the album, and the fight became a cause among fans; titling the record Eight Ninety-Eight was one option considered. The release was delayed while the two sides argued.

Outcome: MCA backed down and Hard Promises was released on May 5, 1981 at the usual $8.98 list price.

Sources: Hard Promises - Wikipedia (citing Los Angeles Times, Feb. 1, 1981, and Musician, July 1981) · May 23, 1979: Tom Petty defies his record label and files for bankruptcy - History.com · Tom Petty - Wikipedia

1987

Licensing · March 1987

Petty sues B.F. Goodrich over a soundalike of "Mary's New Car"

On March 3, 1987 Petty sued B.F. Goodrich in federal court in Los Angeles, saying its radial-tire commercials used a close variation of his song "Mary's New Car". His lawyers said the company's ad agency, Grey Advertising, had asked to buy the rights the previous year and been refused, and that Petty did not license his songs for commercials at all. After viewing the ad, U.S. District Judge J. Spencer Letts found the words, music and tempo very similar and issued a temporary restraining order keeping it off the air.

Outcome: The injunction hearing was cancelled while the sides negotiated, and the case was settled out of court on undisclosed terms.

Sources: Deseret News, March 20, 1987 (Petty Archives copy) · Ocala Star-Banner, March 6, 1987 (Petty Archives copy) · Tom Petty - Wikipedia (citing Los Angeles Times, March 8, 1987)

1988

Record labels

MCA initially turns down Full Moon Fever

When Petty delivered his first solo album, recorded in 1987 and 1988 largely with Jeff Lynne, MCA under Irving Azoff reportedly declined to release it because it did not hear a hit. After Azoff left the label, new management listened again and agreed to put it out.

Outcome: MCA released Full Moon Fever on April 24, 1989, and it became the biggest seller of Petty's career.

Sources: Full Moon Fever - Wikipedia · Initially Rejected By MCA, Tom Petty Issues Full Moon Fever - Songfacts Calendar

1989

Record labels

Secret Warner Bros. contract signed while still owing MCA

In 1989 Petty quietly signed with Warner Bros. Records while still under contract to MCA, which at that point was owed four more albums. The Los Angeles Times reported in April 1992 that the deal, kept secret for about three years, was estimated at $20 million for six albums, and that the success of Full Moon Fever had led to a renegotiation. MCA declined to comment.

Outcome: Petty completed his remaining MCA obligations and later moved to Warner Bros., which released The Last DJ and other albums.

Sources: Chuck Philips, "Petty's Secret Warners Deal Isn't for Petty Cash," Los Angeles Times, April 5, 1992 (Petty Archives copy) · Tom Petty - Wikipedia

2002

Record labels · October 2002

The Last DJ takes aim at the music business

The Last DJ, released by Warner Bros. on October 8, 2002, was built around criticism of greed and corporate practices in the music industry, with the title track inspired by Los Angeles DJ Jim Ladd. Songs including "The Last DJ", "Money Becomes King" and "Joe" carried those themes, and Rolling Stone's reviewer described it as a loose concept album about the industry.

Outcome: The album reached No. 9 on the Billboard 200.

Sources: The Last DJ - Wikipedia · Tom Petty - Wikipedia

2005

Prices · August 2005

Petty keeps concert tickets below market rates

During his 2005 summer tour Petty charged about $30 to $70 a ticket in California, while other veteran acts that year charged up to several hundred dollars. He told Rolling Stone he would be embarrassed to charge $200 and that he had worried since about 1980 about tickets being priced out of ordinary fans' reach. Billboard's Ray Waddell noted Petty booked cities with longtime local promoters rather than taking larger national offers.

Sources: Randy Lewis, "Tom Petty's bucking the big-bucks trend," Los Angeles Times, Aug. 1, 2005 (Petty Archives copy) · Greg Kot, Chicago Tribune, Oct. 29, 2007 (Petty Archives copy)

The Gorge, September 2, 2005
The Gorge, September 2, 2005 · shared by TomFest
2006

Prices · May 2006

Fan-club tickets resold by scalpers are cancelled

In May 2006 Petty's manager Tony Dimitriades and Ticketmaster matched fan-club presale purchases against tickets listed at higher prices on resale sites and voided them: about 460 seats for the June shows in St. Paul and about 800 for Madison Square Garden. Fan-club members agree not to resell, and management called some resale prices outrageous.

Outcome: The voided seats were re-offered to fan-club members with photo ID required at pickup.

Sources: "Tom Petty Fans Get Scalped," Pollstar, May 10, 2006

2006

Songwriting cases · June 2006

Petty declines to pursue "Dani California" similarity

After a Delaware radio show compared the Red Hot Chili Peppers' 2006 single "Dani California" with "Mary Jane's Last Dance", rumors spread that Petty might sue. In a Rolling Stone interview Petty said he doubted any bad intent, noted that many rock songs sound alike, and said he did not believe much in lawsuits unless a song were copied outright and maliciously.

Outcome: No lawsuit was filed.

Sources: Dani California - Wikipedia (citing Rolling Stone, June 28, 2006) · Tom Petty - Wikipedia

2011

Campaign use · June 2011

Petty's camp objects to Bachmann's use of "American Girl"

Michele Bachmann's campaign played "American Girl" at her June 27, 2011 presidential campaign launch in Waterloo, Iowa. Petty's management reportedly sent a letter asking the campaign to stop using the song; reports called it a cease-and-desist, though Petty's agent told CBS News he was unaware of a formal letter.

Outcome: Rolling Stone reported the campaign played the song again the next day.

Sources: Is Tom Petty slapping Bachmann with a cease and desist letter? - CBS News, June 29, 2011 · Tom Petty Issues Cease and Desist to Michele Bachmann - Ultimate Classic Rock, June 29, 2011 · Asawin Suebsaeng, "Tom Petty Against the Machine," Mother Jones, June 28, 2011

2015

Songwriting cases · January 2015

Petty and Jeff Lynne added as writers of "Stay with Me"

Petty's publisher noticed a likeness between Sam Smith's "Stay with Me" and "I Won't Back Down" and contacted Smith's publisher; the matter was settled quietly in late 2014 and made public in January 2015. Petty and Jeff Lynne were added as co-writers and received a 12.5 percent share of the song's royalties. Smith's side called the resemblance a complete coincidence, and Petty said in a statement that it was an honest musical accident, he had no hard feelings, and a lawsuit was never his intention.

Outcome: Petty and Lynne were credited as co-writers with a 12.5% royalty share; no lawsuit was filed.

Sources: I Won't Back Down - Wikipedia (citing BBC News and Rolling Stone, Jan. 2015) · Sam Smith Says Tom Petty Settlement the Result of a 'Complete Coincidence,' Petty Agrees - Ultimate Classic Rock · Tom Petty - Wikipedia

2019

The catalog · December 2019

Tom Petty Legacy LLC formed to manage the catalog

A legal dispute over how Petty's estate and catalog would be managed was settled in December 2019. Tom Petty Legacy, LLC was formed to oversee the music, and Red Light Management's Will Botwin and Coran Capshaw were named to manage the estate day to day.

Outcome: Settlement terms were not disclosed.

Sources: Red Light Management press release, Dec. 18, 2019 · Cox Media Group report via KIRO 7, Dec. 14, 2019

2024

Publishing · July 2024

Estate signs worldwide administration deal with Warner Chappell

On July 1, 2024 the Petty estate announced a worldwide publishing administration deal with Warner Chappell Music covering the large majority of songs Petty wrote, both solo and with the Heartbreakers. Financial terms were not disclosed.

Sources: Tom Petty estate signs global deal with Warner Chappell Music - NBC Los Angeles (City News Service), July 1, 2024 · Tom Petty - Wikipedia (citing Variety, July 1, 2024)

Summaries are drawn from news reports and court filings as cited. See also the labels and executives in our who's who. Spot an error? Tell us.